Infinite and Transcendent Artist Kip Rasmussen on Depicting Tolkiens Silmarillion

Infinite and Transcendent  Artist Kip Rasmussen on Depicting Tolkiens Silmarillion

Jeff LaSala

When I first came across Kip Rasmussens work, I knew it was exceptional, and that Id probably like everything he made. His paintings present all the best components of high fantasy: long hair flowing from beneath helms, brazen swords, gleaming spears, fire-breathing dragons, primordial godlike beings, imposing pinnacles of rock, and an insanely huge spider. Yupthese were scenes right out of J.R.R. Tolkiens legendarium, instantly recognizable as features of Middle-earth. But curiously, only a few of them depict characters in The Lord of the Rings itself. Here was a Silmarillion-leaning artist. Oh, hell yeah.

When I contacted Kip to ask permission to use some of his work in my Silmarillion Primer, he just happened to be mulling over three ideas in his mental queue and he was quick to ask me to choose which subject hed tackle next. I chose Tulkas Chaining Morgoth, so when he finished it later, it was right on time for the War of Wrath segment of the Primer. That made me very happy. And now, once again, Im debuting a new painting in this article: Kips take on that legendary conflict between a certain lionhearted shield-maiden and a certain overconfident lord of carrion.

As soon as I realized I wanted to interview some of my favorite Tolkien artists, I knew Kip Rasmussen would be on the list. Not just because some of his paintings would make awesome Led Zeppelin album coversor frankly, any prog rock album since the 70sbut because hes a down-to-earth human being whos more than meets the eye.

So lets get right to it.

Kip, can you tell me, in a nutshell, how you fell into Tolkiens mythologies? At what age did you first encounter his work, and at what age did you actually sink in deep beyond the point of no return?

Kip: At age 8, I found The Hobbit on my brothers bookshelf, opened it, and that was it right there. I couldnt believe what I had found. I still cant believe it. I moved right into The Lord of the Rings and the free fall continued. I remember sitting in class in fourth grade reading the Moria passage, stressing out visibly. A classmate looked over and said, Whats wrong? I barely looked up and lamented, Gandalf just died! Poor kid looked very confused.

Obviously this was before Gandalf became a household name, becaus

e of the films. (Though arguably, he already was a name in some households, but thats another story.)

Túrin Approaches the Pool of Ivrin by Kip Rasmussen

Now, I know you as a kick-ass painter who favors Tolkien above all. But youre also an author and film producer? Can you tell me about that?

Kip: I work with the filmmaker Tom Durham. We met at a party and found we shared a love of science fiction and fantasy. He directs the films and I help him with a bunch of tasks involved in independent filmshelp with story ideas, concept art, props, fundraising, etc. His first feature is 95ers: Time Runners, which is a time travel thriller. He is now involved in a wonderful local television show which tells the story of the ups and downs of the lives of everyday people. Kind of the idea that everyone has a story to tell. Our goal is to move into a multi-season science fiction or fantasy series such as can be found on channels nearly everywhere. He is a tremendously talented artist with infinite energy.

Nice! And hey, my brothers got the DVD, even backed the Kickstarter for that film. And yeah, you have an IMDB page, dont you? Keep growing that! But youre also a therapist, too, right?

Kip: Yes. My day job is as a family therapist and I have published a book on parenting. I took what forty years of research has revealed about the most effective parenting elements and derived easily usable tips from that body of research. The cool thing is that, because of that research, we dont really have to guess much anymore. In a nutshell, the most effective parenting involves a lot of love and support coupled with some reasonable rules applied as gently as possible to get the job done. We dont have to yell or punish in the traditional sense. We just have to make sure we lean enough that kids follow the rules that will help them be successful in their lives without triggering their natural impulse to be defiant against us. Its been very helpful with my own kids and the kids of my clients.

What do you mean by lean?

Kip: I use the comparison of the weight of the leaning elephant rather than a charging, trampling, or goring elephant. Kids are awesome and if we are just insistent and lean on them when they need correcting, the research shows that we get better long-term results. If we yell, we generally get short-term compliance, but we also show them that we are out of control and they tend to not trust us as much. Most of us hate being bossed around and kids are very prone to defiance if they feel we are abusing our authority. This all hits the fan when they turn 13 or 14.

Im officially bookmarking this article to refer back to in a few years, in that case! Thanks. So before I circle back to Tolkien specifically, whats your authorship status?

Kip: I am expanding a novella about two warriors who venture into a mountain fastness to try to kill a dragon-like creature which has been terrorizing their city. They dont expect to live long but what they find is much worse than they foresaw. Its fun to build a world, something which yet again shows me how astonishing Tolkiens genius was.

I know, its downright intimidatingthat is, doing your own world-building when youre a Tolkien fan. But its still worth doing. Like that time when Morgoth, the first Dark Lord of Middle-earth wanted to destroy the Two Trees of Valinor but needed the help of the hideously powerful, light-craving Ungoliant. He had to work out an agreement with her, and she was difficult, and it didnt ultimately go swimmingly for him. Say, you painted that outcome

Ungoliant Ensnares Morgoth by Kip Rasmussen

But it was worth it in the long run, is my point. He did manage to destroy the Trees, sow chaos in Valinor, and make off with those shiny Silmarils. Likewise, its a lot of extra work to devise your own setting in the shadow of what Tolkien didbut that doesnt mean you shouldnt try.

So, I would say that most casual fans of Tolkien understandably extol and reread The Lord of the Rings or The Hobbit. A smaller percentage, from what I can tell, really know The Silmarillion well or have even read it. But even a quick look at your websites gallery reveals that, in fact, most of your work is based on that book. Youve called it more fundamental than his other books, and one of the most preeminent works of art ever created. And I certainly agree! Can you elaborate, or give any specific examples of why you think so? Do you find it a more enjoyable read, page by page?

Kip: All of Tolkiens work has its glory. Unfinished Tales is probably my second favorite book. But The Silmarillion is just so infinite and transcendent. It takes everything we love about The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings and gives us exponentially more. More gods, Elves, Balrogs, dragons, battles, marvelous cities and dwellings, love stories, and origin stories. If we want to learn about where everything comes from, from Elves to stars, from Ents to Orcs, its there. Tolkien forgot almost nothing. The origin story of Dwarves and Ents is particularly fascinating because it involves a fundamental disagreement about the nature of the world from a couple of married gods! Also, could there be anything more riveting than the story of Beren and Lúthien, in which a woman saves her love from death several times, eventually literally from the God of the Underworld himselfby singing of her eternal love? So many, many timeless themes, from our relationship to authority and God (Morgoth, Ulmo, and Fëanor), to the nature of sacrifice and suffering (Barahir and Finrod), to the self-destructive pride of the most talented among us (Fëanor, Turgon, Túrin, Thingol) to the necessity of reigning in our darkness (Maeglin, Ar-Pharazôn).

Well, you get points just for name-dropping Finrod. But maybe thats just me. Oh, and speaking of Thingol, you illustrated his famous meeting with the songbird-themed Maia, Melian, in the forest of Nan Elmoth. This is easily one of my favorites. Ill share that one further down.

Anyway, go on.

Kip: The Silmarillion is not just one of the greatest works of serious world literature, but one of the greatest achievements in all of artistic endeavor. For me, it is by far the greatest work by the most expansive single creative mind of all time. Other than the really important things such as family, etc., my most cherished dream in life is to introduce this magnificent creative achievement to those who might appreciate it. But it can be a locked treasure trove because of all the new names. It took three times reading it for me to understand what was happening. But if people can be helped through images to get through all the new names, I hope it can lift them like it has me.

Only three? Good on you! But yeah, youre certainly right. If anyone asks me what my favorite single book of all time is, I dodge around The Lord of the Rings using the flimsy three-book excuse (because of course it isnt three separate books in the authors mind) and so now I just say The Silmarillion.

Ive noticed theres a fascinating sort of zoomed in style in your works, in contrast to other Tolkien artists, where its clearly focused on an individual, monster, or scene, and yet the landscape is stretched out behind them in a verystretchy way, if that makes sense? Almost like youve got a sort of Ken Burns effect on your paintings at all times. Like with your illustration Beren and Lúthien Plight Their Troth. I find myself looking at the figures at the top, then gradually pan down and marvel at the curiously treacherous yet beautiful place theyve chosen to pledge undying love! Its cool.

Beren and Lúthien Plight Their Troth by Kip Rasmussen

And in Tuor and Voronwë Seek Gondolin, you either look first at the jutting mountains and then notice the travelers at the bottom or else you see them first then sweep upward and gape at the frozen challenge ahead of them. How do you do that? Can you talk about your style a little bit?

Kip: What is this new devilry? You are totally reading my artistic mind. Its a seriously perceptive tribute. Thank you. Tolkiens world is nearly infinite and The Silmarillion is for me a book in which immortal, meteoric characters are nonetheless caught up in events which overwhelm and consume them. For all the greatness and glory of Fëanor, Melian, Túrin, and Turgon, they are caught in a struggle which is worthy of depiction in all ways, but which they cannot win. The world and the themes are bigger than they are. I love depicting these environments to show the difficulty of the task they have ahead of them. Tolkiens landscapes can be sinister and malevolent. Mirkwood, the Old Forest, and the Dead Marshes are all enemies which strive to hinder the heroes. I love painting stone, trees, and especially mountains as much as I love warriors and dragons. Tolkien was essentially made of the organic stuff of the earth. The landscapes are often active characters and they deserve their own portraits. Caradhras the Cruel, for example, is a living entity and will receive a close-up soon. I feel an urgency, a suffocating yearning to depict Middle-earth itself. For me, its kind of like the One Ring. I want viewers to be immersed in that marvelous world. This is what moves me so much about the work of Ted Nasmith and Alan Lee. They really breathe the misty, fathomless depths of Arda.

Wow. Well, given how much youve personified features of geographyas Tolkien certainly did with characters like Caradhras, as you suggestnow I have to ask you my first hypothetical question. If you were one of the Ainur whod help sing the World into shape (Eä, or at least Arda itself), which named geological feature or landscape would be your favorite? It would be one that, maybe, youd have had a hand in making? For example, the River Sirion in Beleriand was unquestionably Ulmos favorite river of all time (and that guy knew rivers!).

Kip: Probably the water-carved arch of Alqualondë. There are a lot of them I would like to have taken credit for: the Echoriath, the Pelóri , etc. Im crazy about mountains. I love unusual rock features. I might have some Dwarvish blood :)

Then I think youd probably be a Maia in service to Aulë. Of course, his Maiar dont have the best track record. But it does make sense. Those who worked with Aulë, the Great Smith, are intrinsically crafters and sub-creators. Painters would fit in there nicely.

What sort of paints do you use and why? And do you ever do anything digitally?

Kip: I started out in oils but found that they dry slowly and the clean-up can be messy. I switched to acrylics, which are kind of unforgiving but work for me since I cant devote full time to painting. I would love to learn the digital world but I am a more organic person. For example, I create Japanese-style gardens and love physically arranging trees, rocks, and dirt. Its a tactile thing for me. I like physically applying paint rather than drawing on glass. I am about to go back to oils, I think, since I have discovered additives which can help them dry quicker, and that there are alternatives to toxic solvents as well. But oils blend easily and are more luminous. Frankly, I am still learning to paint both artistically and technically. Boris Vallejo once described painting as a dance. For me, its a kind of combat. I lose often and even when I produce something to show the world, its from a series of compromises with time and skill level. Every painting is a low-key haunting regarding what I originally wanted to do but couldnt pull off. Its a blessing and a curse to paint the work of Tolkien. I never want to disappoint Tolkien or Tolkien fans. They deserve the best I can muster up.

Speaking of mustering Rohan! Youve recently tackled one of the Rohirrim ancestor-kings, Fram, and his legendary slaying of everybodys favorite scathing hoarder, the long-worm known as Scatha!

Scatha and Fram by Kip Rasmussen

You know, with only a couple of exceptions, Ive noticed that whenever youve got only two characters depicted in a given painting, theyre either falling in love with each other or trying to kill each other. Just an observation.

So talk to me about dragons. What sets Tolkiens apart from all the rest?

Kip: Tolkiens dragons are not just content to be powerful and destructive, they are also malevolent. Glaurung, for example, wasnt content to just kill Túrin, but to destroy Túrins mind and family. Really disturbing. For me, its one of the most tragic stories ever written. Just gut-wrenching. Tolkiens dragons have a vicious intelligence. One does not simply ride a Tolkien dragon, at least not the organic kind.

Dragons of Tolkien collage by Kip Rasmussen

So where is a region of Middle-earthor anywhere in Ardathat you wish Tolkien had fleshed out more? If you got an exclusive description from the hand of the professor himself of one place, character, or scene, where would that be?

Kip: When we describe Tolkien, we should start at genius and then go upward from there. And he spent all of his life building this world. And yet its never enough for us. We want more. I wish he had described virtually all lands a little more rather than playing cards. Apparently he loved a form of solitaire called patience.

Anyway, Id love to hear more about Valinor. And the actual structure of Rivendell? Was it the last homely house or a fortress compound as it appears in the war involving Celebrimbor? I know Gondolin was described pretty well, but Id dearly love an actual map. I want to see Númenor, a nation so magnificent that it astounded Sauron himself.

Thats too many answers! (But theyre all good ones.)

Kip: Ive struggled to understand how to depict bright Eärendil. Was he just so good that he shone or was it that he literally glowed? The most curious passage though is how he possibly could have killed Ancalagon while in his ship. That one needs clarification.

Hah! Well, I think the diamond dust dust he kicked up outside of Tirion was a contributing factor. And I think its like glitter; once its on you, its on you for good. Especially Noldorin gem-glitter. But given that by that time hed already strapped the Silmaril to his brow, the dude was a walking nebula of awesome already. But yes, the chapter starts with him being called Bright Eärendil. Still, I think thats because the narrator is speaking in the past tense; he already knows what Eärendils fate will be in the telling.

All right, setting aside all existing films and movie scores, if you had the power to point to a living musician or band of musicians and they had to (lets say got to) put together an album of Middle-earth music, who would you choose?

Kip: This group is really good: Clamavi De Profundis. Loreena McKennitt has the most marvelously haunted voice. For me this could be Yavanna singing for the trees or Lúthien lamenting the death of Thingol. As for those not living 

Breaking the rules again, I see.

Kip: there are several. I know these are in Latin and theyre specifically Catholic but they feel so Elvish to me. Both kind of fit for Tolkien, though. For example, for me, this piece is the Music of the Ainur. Also, the work of the mighty polymath Hildegard Von Bingen just transports me to Arda. And for those who arent overtly religious, heres one about the plants she wrote about. Like everything in the natural world, Tolkien loved plants, too.

Close enough to my actual question, I guess, you scofflaw. But I dig em, and I concur especially that McKennitt could have rendered us some excellent Middle-earth music. Why hasnt she? Alas.

Okay, back to painting. Youve just finished this piece, Éowyn Stands Against the Witch-king. Now, this is not only the favorite scene of many a Tolkien fan, but its also a beloved moment to paint. But every Tolkien artist does it differently, as they should. Some show the Nazgûls beast already slain, some have Éowyn delivering that fateful strike. Youve shown them simply squaring off, the outcome uncertain.

Éowyn Stands Against the Witch-king by Kip Rasmussen

Can you tell me why you chose this particular moment in time, and about your angle?

Kip: I had done a compositional sketch and the gesture of Éowyn was so perfect that I tried to copy it in the larger painting. I was much less successful in doing so but didnt have the chops to really change it so that it matched the energy and immediacy of the sketch. In the sketch, she was kind of hunkered down bracing for the onslaught. My reference photo looked good in camera but looked too stiff when it was painted. It just happens like that sometimes. That painting really strained my current abilities and took a ton of time. I like it less than some others and want to do another one when I have improved because its probably the most iconic scene in Tolkiens body of work, which is saying something. I just dont have the energy in my figures that Frazetta does, not that many artists ever have. I do have a nefarious plan to try to get better and better and give the Tolkien work the treatment of Vermeer or Caravaggio. Nothing like pressure!

As far as the moment of the painting, I wanted it to have a bit of potential energy. She could still run away if she lost her nerve in the face of this horror, but her protective instincts are so great that she stays and fights. It just felt like the tipping point a bit. I did the same thing with Thingol and Melian, where they hadnt yet sealed their relationship by clasping hands so it is still up in the air. A bit more dramatic tension, I suppose.

See, I hadnt thought about thatElwë seems to fall so fast and hard for Melian that its easy to forget how much time really goes by in their meeting, technically. Years, in fact, maybe far more once they actually join hands. And then, of course, its after this meeting that he goes by the name Thingol. Because renaming is what Elves do.

Thingol and Melian by Kip Rasmussen

All right, now for some easy lightning round questions. Regardless of the subjects of your own illustrations, who is

Your favorite Elf of the First Age?

Kip: There would be many. Fingolfin fought Morgoth! Fingon rescued Maedhros. Turgon built that city. Eärendil brought on the War of Wrath. Idril was just such a great maternal figure. I love Beleg also. But probably the favorite is Finrod, who just knew he was going to die but had to honor his oath.

I only let you rattle off multiple answers because you did conclude with the greatest Elf of all ages of the world. Finrod for the win! Not only did he have Berens back, he also made first contact with Men and arguably ensured the Edain, and thereby the Dúnedain, would come to pass. If any other Beleriand Elf had encountered Men first, especially one of the sons of Fëanor, the story might have been very different.

Favorite mortal man or woman of the First or Second Age?

Kip: Tuor, but Húrin comes in a close second.

Favorite minion or monster of Morgoth?

Kip: Ancalagon. Sooooo huge.

Ancalagon Departing for the War of Wrath by Kip Rasmussen

A Dwarf you wish we knew much more about?

Kip: Durin the Deathless, the original.

A.K.A. Aulës very first stab at a creature of his own. The prototype. But yeah, Durins cool.

One more question. Youre an experienced parent and a therapist and a lifelong Tolkien fan. How could one get a childsay, a 5-year-oldwell on his way to becoming a solid Tolkien reader without one coming on too strong? Asking for a friend.

Kip: Thats the question a great parent asks. Seriously.

Pair the experiences with Tolkien with some good times with you. I watched Fellowship with my son when he was five and it didnt seem so scary for him. I watched it after we made brownies together, then watched Wallace & Gromit afterward. He still considers it the most cherished memory of his childhood. Not sure you want to introduce him to the books using the movies, but if he feels a closeness to you, he will naturally have an affinity for Tolkien. Be the good parent you seem to be and have the material around and he will most likely start to love it. Read The Hobbit to him for his bedtime story over the course of weeks. You both are probably in for a treat. I talk about it all the time with my grown son. Good luck!

Thanks! And thanks for giving your time and sharing your work. Folks should check our your websiteand whaaaat, you can get a phone case with your art on it?

Id like to end by displaying one more recent piece of yours. For all your Silmarillion pieces, youve still clearly got a few Third Age-related soft spots, like this one. What made you depict the animal that the horses of the Nine cannot vie with, who is tireless, swift as the flowing wind, and whose coat glistens like silver and by night is like a shadow?

Seriously, Tolkien gives Shadowfax more of a physical description than Legolas!

Shadowfax on the Highlands of Rohan by Kip Rasmussen

Kip: As we all know, there are many astonishing scenes that beg depicting in Tolkiens work. I have a queue that is literally hundreds of images long. So, if enough fans at conventions ask for a certain image, I move it up the list. People love their gods, Elves, and dragons, but horse lovers are very passionate. And I love painting horses. Challenging but dynamic. The Shadowfax painting came together better than most for some reason.

Its also a wonderful moment of peace, even though its bursting with energy and force. This is Shadowfax, chief of the Mearas, at play.

Thank you for your time and your visions, Kip!

Okay, wait, notheres still one more I need to share. Kips has several new Tolkien-inspired paintings that have debuted since this interview, and everyone reading this should totally check them out on his website. Youve got Gandalf and the Witch-king, Aulë and Yavanna, the father of Dwarves (Durin!) taking the longest nap ever, a close-up of Ancalagons fearsome mug staring down tiny Vingolot, and more. Not on his site (yet) is a really striking one: Olórin in the Gardens of Lórien. Yes, thats a beardless Gandalf taking a moment to breathe in Valinor. His sorrow is deep.

But I also wanted to share one new painting right here. This is Morgoth Musters the Winged Dragons for the War of Wrath, and aside from it being another display of Kips tall, sweeping compositions, we get to see Morgoth flanked by some of his greater servantswhich gives one artists interpretation of scale. A troll, a black-robed figure whos got to be Sauron, a Balrog (look, Mom, no wings!), and an Orc looking like hes in way over his head in present company. All of them are dwarfed by the dragons.

I love the fact that the setting is a dark pit in the depths of Angband, a dark contrast to Kips wintry Ancalagon Departing for the War of Wrath shown earlier. These wyrms havent yet taken to the skies to terrorize Beleriand. But they are clearly eager to stretch those wings and snack on some Elves and Men.

Morgoth Musters His Winged Dragons for the War of Wrath by Kip Rasmussen

Top image from Varda of the Stars by Kip Rasmussen.

An earlier version of this article was originally published in February 2019.

Jeff LaSala, whos personally responsible for The Silmarillion Primer, will now hold Kip Rasmussen personally responsible for his own son growing up right. Tolkien geekdom aside, Jeff wrote a Scribe Awardnominated D&D novel, produced some cyberpunk stories, and now works for Tor Books. He sometimes flits about on Twitter.

                                                                                                                's eBook of the Month Club

Kip Rasmussen

. , .